Understanding The Max Pain Theory Near Options Expiration

The “Max Pain” theory, also sometimes called the Strike Price Pegging, as it relates to options trading refers to the changes in the price of an underlying stock as it gets closer to its option expiration date.

According to the theory, most traders trading options are likely to experience painful losses on average over time. Thus, the stock will tend to move to an area that causes the most pain (i.e. losses) for the highest number of options traders.

Stocks Move Toward The Middle

The maximum pain theory assumes that most of the option contracts (Calls or Puts) will expire worthless on the option expiry date. What happens is that during the last few days of trading for the month, the price of the underlying stock will move toward the pain point.

This strike price is the value where most option traders will lose their money as the options expire worthless, causing everyone long to go broke.

A Simple But Powerful Illustration

For example, let’s say that a Call option contract for a company, named ABC, costs $200 premium and has a strike price of $40. It has an expiration date of one month out or 30 days. The trader strongly believes that the stock will rise in the coming month. Therefore, he purchases the call option by paying the $200 premium.

And let’s say that yet another trader bought a Put option contract because he felt that the stock price will fall within the coming month. He purchased the put option by paying the premium at the time; $200 per contract.

If the stock closes at $40, the Max Pain Price, both the call and put options would expire with a value of $0.00. This is the point at which both traders (long and short) would lose money. Make sense now?

Here’s Option Max Pain Calculator

A really great website and tool to help determine the strike prices that are likely to cause the most pain is OptionPain.com. There you can literally type in the ticker symbol, expiration month, and strike price range and it will visually show you where the stock is likely to close to cause most option buyers to lose money.

In the example above I used the SPY February contract which expires next week to show you what it looks like visually. Right now it shows us that the max pain point would be for the SPY to close around $130. Since it’s currently trading at $134 this would mean a sizable decline in the next week.

Again this is an awesome tool to check out for all your open positions as you near expiration.

Theory Is Of Course Just Theory

Especially when it comes to the stock and options market, nothing is certain. I’ve seen this work in both directions in the past – sometimes to surprising accuracy. Should you base your entire expiration week strategy on this; No. But you should at least be aware of it after all.

Enough of my thoughts on this subject…Do you think this theory works? Have you had success with it before? Add your comments below and share your experiences.

  • Bill Place

    Thanks Kirk

  • brian

    This ties into a expiation day trade straregy called pinning where stock usually reverts to strikes with highest open interest and in direction that most calls or puts are to expire out of money

  • DAVE J

    I am assuming this is based on all open contracts on diffferent strikes, so I someone has purchased a 130 Put on SPY and another person has sold 130 Put …then the latter would actually benefit if SPY closed at 130. When I look at the bloomberg screen, I can see all the open contracts and volume but is there a way of telling why is long and who is short those options? And if not, how does this tool have any value at all?

    • Kirk

      @DAVE J, From what they say over at OptionPain.com they only use remaining long contracts that are open. Since the indicator is based on finding the stock price that brings maximum loss to option buyers it is limited in it’s effectiveness now showing net sellers. With anything we just have to take it for what it is – but it’s still useful.