
Start Here
Platform

Tour
Bots 101How it worksLive demo
Tools
Automated tradingOptions backtestingWatchlist scannerPrivate community
Use cases
New investorsStock tradersActive tradersPassive investorsSwing tradersAlgorithmic traders

Templates
By trade type
Stock trading botsOptions trading bots
By strategy type
Bullish options strategiesNeutral options strategiesBearish options strategiesHedging strategies
By style
Active and high frequency botsEvent-based botsTrend trading botsMomentum trading botsStatistic and probability-based botsTechnical analysis botsEarnings strategy bots

Integrations

Pricing
Education

Courses
Overview
By experience
Beginner
What is an options contract?Stock trading vs. options tradingOptions contract specificsCall vs. put options basicsBuying options vs. selling optionsOptions profit and loss diagramsOptions pricing tablesOption moneyness (ITM, OTM, and ATM)Options pricing and the "Greeks"Options expiration and assignmentWhat's our "edge" trading options?Single vs. multi-leg options strategiesSmall account options strategies
Intermediate
Fearless, confident options tradingHistorical volatility vs. implied volatilityPredicting market movesTrade size and capital reservesPortfolio balance and beta weightingHow to choose the best options strategyHow far out to place trades?Strike price anchoring with probabilitiesTips on getting your trades filledAdvanced and contingent orders7 step options trade entry checklist
Advanced
Developing a daily trading routineHow to avoid "Black Swan" eventsAdjusting and hedging option tradesExiting options trades automaticallyOptions strategies we don't adjust (and why)Big picture adjustment strategyWhen to adjust or notAdjusting straddles and stranglesAdjusting credit spreads, iron condors, and calendarsSmarter stop-loss ordersBuilding a diversified options portfolioRolling options trades for duration and premiumOptions expiration week position checklistDealing with stock assignment and dividendsHow to free up trading margin and cash
By subject
Options basics
Why options vs. stocks?What is an options contract?Smart use of leverageOption strike priceOption premiumOption expirationOption contract multiplierProfit and loss diagramsLong call option explainedShort call option explainedLong put option explainedShort put option explainedATM, ITM, and OTM optionsCash vs. margin basicsHigh probability trading definedHow to buy a call optionHow to buy a put optionSingle-leg vs. multi-legWhat is the VIX?Is fundamental analysis dead?
Entering and exiting trades
Game of numbers7 step entry checklistStrong liquidity examplesPicking the next directionScanning for tradesOption pricing table basicsSetting up your trade tabPinning your probability of profitUsing delta for probabilitiesBuy to open vs sell to openBuy to close vs sell to closeMarket, limit, stop loss orders5 types of contingent ordersLimit ordersMarket ordersLimit on close ordersMarket on close ordersAdvanced contingent ordersTaking profits before expirationMechanics of rollingConsider future events
Options expiration
Options expiration explainedWhat is the Options Clearing Corporation (OCC)?Physical vs. cash settlement optionsAmerican vs. European style optionsWeekly options expirationWeekly expiration tags/codesOptions assignment processOptions exercise processTrading timeline (duration)
Bullish options strategies
Bull put spreadBull call spreadLong callShort putBull call backspreadPut broken wing butterflyCall calendar spreadPut diagonal spreadCustom naked putCovered callSynthetic long stock
Neutral options strategies
Short straddleLong straddleIron condorsShort strangleLong strangleIron butterflyUnbalanced iron condors
Bearish options strategies
Bear call spreadBear put spreadLong putShort callBear put backspreadCall broken wing butterflyPut calendar spreadCall diagonal spreadCustom naked callCovered putSynthetic short stock
Portfolio managmeent
No guaranteed tradesDon't do something, sit thereAccount size adjustmentsAvoiding stock market overloadStocks, indexes, & ETFsMonitoring positionsCreating automatic alertsIndividual stock betaPortfolio betaBeta weighting your portfolioUncorrelated industries/sectorsSystematic vs. unsystematic riskEfficient portfolio frontierLimiting undefined risk tradesEconomic calendarConcept of legging
Options pricing and volatility
How to find option price quotesUnderstanding the mathIV vs. IV percentileProbability of profit vs. probability of touchOption probability curveBid-ask spread definedIV expected vs. actual moveThe "Greeks"Fatal pricing errorsInverse ETFsOptions parity
Adjusting trades
#1 adjustment for any tradeWhen to adjust a tradeSingle options trade vs. overall portfolioLeveraging the analyze tabCall spread adjustmentsPut spread adjustmentsShort strangle adjustmentsIron condor adjustmentsShort straddle adjustmentsCalendar spread adjustmentsDebit spread adjustmentsButterfly adjustmentsUsing stop lossesDelta hedgingRolling positionsPairs hedging

Strategies
Long callLong putShort callShort putCovered callCovered putProtective putCollar strategyLEAPSBull call debit spreadBear call credit spreadBull put credit spreadBear put debit spreadLong straddleShort straddleLong strangleShort strangleCall calendar spreadPut calendar spreadIron condorReverse iron condorIron butterflyReverse iron butterflyCall butterflyPut butterflyStrapCall diagonal spreadPut diagonal spreadCall ratio spreadPut ratio spreadCall backspreadPut backspreadLong box spreadShort box spreadReversalStock repair

Topics
OverviewAsset allocationAutomated tradingBehavioral financeBrokersCandlestick patternsChart patternsDividendsEconomic indicatorsEquity investmentsExercise & assignmentFinancial analysisFinancial historyFinancial marketsFinancial modelingFinancial theoriesFundamental analysisFuturesInvestment accountsInvestment taxesInvestor biasesMarket holidaysMarket hoursMarket indexesMarket indicatorsMomentum tradingOptionsOptions pricingOptions settlementPortfolio managementRisk managementStocksStock marketTechnical analysisTechnical indicatorsTrading commissionsTrading platformsTrading psychologyTrend trading
Resources

Workshops

Podcast

Blog
Support

Help Center
Overview
Getting started
What is a bot?Creating a botAutomation typesAutomation editorBot dashboardBot positionsBot logTemplates and cloningKey conceptsSafeguards and limitsPower of botsBest practices
Bot automations
What is an automation?Scanner automationsMonitor automationsEvent automationsEditing automationsReusing automationsCopying automationsOrdering automationsUsing custom inputsBot level inputsAutomation statusesAutomations library
Bot actions
DecisionsOpen positionClose positionNotificationsLoop symbolsLoop positionsBot tagsPosition tags
Bot examples
Genesis 1.0 botGenesis 2.0 botGenesis 3.0 botTrend trading with stocks botPortfolio trend trading botTrend trading with options botMultiple moving averages botTechnical swing trading botTrend and momentum botWeekly credit spread botRecurring iron condors botThe "Honey Badger" botHybrid spreads botHigh IV rank iron condor bot
Decision recipes
Comparing underlying symbol priceEvaluating symbol typeComparing underlying symbol propertiesEvaluating underlying symbol performanceEvaluating underlying symbol standard deviationComparing underlying symbol price to an indicatorComparing multiple underlying symbol indicatorsEvaluating underlying symbol implied volatility rankEvaluating underlying symbol earnings reportingEvaluating underlying symbol price probabilityEvaluating underlying symbol probability within rangeEvaluating bot propertiesEvaluating bot available capital for opportunitiesComparing bot position count to position typeComparing bot position count to underlying symbolEvaluating bot position count to position type and underlying symbolEvaluating bot last position activityEvaluating bot last activity with underlying symbolComparing bot active orders statusComparing bot active orders status with underlying symbolEvaluating bot position availabilityEvaluating bot tagsEvaluating opportunity availabilityEvaluating opportunity return expectationsComparing opportunity attributesComparing opportunity leg attributesComparing opportunity bid-ask spreadEvaluating opportunity probabilitiesEvaluating position performanceComparing profit target to trailing valueComparing position time to expirationComparing position durationEvaluating position underlying symbolComparing position propertiesComparing position leg propertiesEvaluating position typeEvaluating position sideComparing underlying symbol price to position legEvaluating position tagsEvaluating underlying symbol indicator propertiesComparing multiple underlying symbol indicator propertiesEvaluating MACD technical indicatorComparing Bollinger Bands to symbol priceEvaluating stochastic technical indicatorComparing VIX propertiesEvaluating market time of the dayEvaluating days of the weekEvaluating bot switches
Position statement
Activity summaryPosition detailsTrade detailsOpened positionsClosed positionsCanceled positionsOverride positionsExpired positionsPosition historyManually open positionManually close positionImport position
Order pricing
SmartPricingFinal price settingsPosition summaryOrder detailsWorking ordersManual override
Bot templates
Creating new templatesUpdating existing templatesDeleting templatesSharing templatesUpdating shared templatesTemplate best practices
Cloning bots
Cloning existing botsCloning from templateCloning from shared template
Troubleshooting
Using bot logsTesting your botsNot enough capital warningDaily position limit warningTotal position limit warningPricing anomaly warningMissing or invalid input errorDaily symbol limit errorExcessive errors failsafeOverlapping strikes failsafePrice exceeds strike-difference errorOptions expiration protocolDuplicate orders errorOptions approval level errorBot event loopsStock splits and corporate actionsSupported browsersSupported countries
Community forum
Community guidelinesCrafting your introductionSending group messagesSending private messagesAttaching bot templatesReceiving bot templatesAttaching automationsReceiving automationsFollowing tradersPosting publiclyEditing posts and messagesSubscribed discussionsUsing bookmarks
Using backtester
Running a new backtestBacktesting results summaryModifying existing backtestsMy backtestsBacktesting research databaseTop backtestsBacktesting errors
Account settings
My profileTrading accountsConnecting to TDAmeritradeConnecting to TradeStationConnecting to TradierIncompatible accountsPassword managementSession timeoutTwo-step authentication
Technical docs
Infrastructure and securityAutomation structureAutomation behaviorData feedsOrder handlingTrade enforcementsBroker rejection errorsBot limitationsProfit and lossFair value pricingDecision propertiesDecision calculationsParameter selectionCalculating probabilityPlatform indicators

Contact
Send FeedbackReport IssueEmail Us
Option AlphaOption Alpha

LoginFree Trial
BlogResearch InsightsTail Risk Pricing Post-Pandemic

Tail Risk Pricing Post-Pandemic

VIX and SPX tail risk pricing is astronomically high compared to before the pandemic. What has happened to the price of downside protection? Find out here.
Tail Risk Pricing Post-Pandemic
Ryan Hysmith
Oct 20, 2021
•
9 min read





Flashback: March 2020. The pandemic that at first was regionally contained has become a global health threat with increasing financial implications. Markets are falling fast, triggering circuit breakers and leaving unprepared traders overexposed and saddled with losing positions. 

The Pandemic Crash was the fastest drop in history from all-time highs to correction territory.

Historical chart of S&P market corrections

Hedged traders were not totally immune to the panic, but their portfolios were more stable and better prepared to capitalize on the subsequent rally than those without portfolio protection. 

Strategies like Option Alpha’s VIX hedging strategy or buying deep-out-of-the-money (OTM) put options (i.e., “unit puts”) were incredibly effective during the Pandemic Crash. However, today’s pricing of VIX options and OTM puts has dramatically reduced the same strategies’ price efficiency and downside protection.

Traders talk about VIX and SPX tail risk pricing being astronomically high compared to before the pandemic. How significant is this price change? What has happened to the price of downside protection?

We studied almost two decades of deep-OTM SPX put option pricing data to get you the answers. 

Hedging Tail Risk with OTM Puts

One way to hedge a portfolio is to purchase far OTM put contracts on major indices. Certain put contracts are sometimes referred to as “units” or “unit puts” because they trade at round dollar amounts or specific deltas, and each contract represents a “unit” of protection.

A unit put is a far out-of-the-money put contract with Greeks that do not follow the uniform patterns of closer-to-the-money contracts. Low delta unit puts react uniquely during volatility events. Worried investors buy downside protection en masse, causing a positive feedback loop as demand exceeds supply, creating an “explosion” in far OTM put pricing.

This explosion provides downside protection (a hedge) that can protect an investor from disastrous losses and possibly even generate a profit during significant market volatility. 

Many authors have described the repricing of low delta options during volatility events. See Chen and Sebastian’s The Option Trader’s Hedge Fund for further discussion on unit puts or Krishnan’s The Second Leg Down for more on options pricing in a volatile environment. 

Traders have several options for strike and expiration selection when hedging with OTM puts. For example, you could hedge by regularly buying the front month, .05 delta SPX put option. Figure 2 shows the profitability of a series of those individual trades, rolling into new contracts at 15 DTE. Each data point in the plot is a particular trade’s profit or loss. 

Figure 2 - SPX 5 Delta, Front Month Individual Trades' Profit

This hedging strategy served its purpose in March 2020. The highest bar shows the profit for a closed put contract on March 12, 2020. That single trade produced $24,770 as the front month, .05 delta put increased 3,440% in 15 days.

While the hedge was effective during that volatility, the contracts in this example typically expired worthless, leaving the holder with a slight loss (the cost of the put option). This creates a long-term portfolio drag, shown in Figure 3 by plotting the cumulative profit (loss) of the strategy.

Figure 3 - Cumulative P&L from SPX 5 Delta Hedge

Like the VIX “Doomsday Hedge,” the protection from unit puts was well worth the cost during the Pandemic Crash. But, the constant protection put buying in the years leading up to the crash created sustained portfolio drag. What does pricing look like today?

SPX Options Pricing Case Study

Hedging to avoid or mitigate portfolio losses during significant market declines is a popular topic. A diversified investor can handle small losses, but correction-level events take a toll on the unprotected investor’s long-term returns. But how much are you willing to pay for that protection?

Just as homeowner’s insurance increases after a series of storms, the price of hedging increases as a result of market volatility. By how much does it increase, and how long does it last?

Using SPX options data from February 2005 through July 2021, we studied the magnitude and duration of pricing volatility.

Downside Protection Pricing Changes

There is no strict definition of tail-risk protection puts (“unit puts”), so we analyzed 15 combinations of DTE and deltas. We considered 30, 45, 60, 90, and 120 DTE contracts, each with the .03, .05, and .10 deltas.

To understand pricing changes, we calculated the mid-price for the contract that best fit our criteria each day at 3:45 PM EST. We evaluated all expiration types, tracking the contract that best matched our defined DTE and delta, regardless of weekly, monthly, or quarterly expiration. We split our data into equal-sized pre and post-Pandemic Crash datasets.

  • Pre-Pandemic Crash Dataset: 10/24/2018 - 3/16/2020 (n=348)
  • Post-Pandemic Crash Dataset: 3/16/2020 - 7/30/2021 (n=348)

 Figure 4 shows the average contract prices before and after the Pandemic Crash.

Figure 4 - Average Contract Price

The blue points correspond to the right-side axis and show the percentage change between pre and post-pandemic pricing. 

The cost of deep-out-of-the-money puts after the Pandemic Crash is significantly higher, with some contracts nearly doubling their average mid-price. 

The average price increase for all definitions of unit puts shown in Figure 4 is +89%.

All unit-put definitions showed a sustained pricing increase following the Pandemic Crash, but pricing increases were larger in higher DTE contracts and lower delta contracts.

While there are clear relationships, the right-side y-axis’ relatively narrow range of +80-100% shows us that the differences in price increases between contracts is small.

The minimum price change was +80% by the .10 delta, 30 DTE contract, and the maximum average increase was +100% by the .03 delta, 120 DTE contract. 

Looking at pricing from a different angle, Figure 5 shows contract pricing for the .05 delta, 30 DTE puts and .05 delta, 120 DTE puts, overlaid with VIX values.

Figure 5 - SPX 5 Delta 30 DTE and SPX 5 Delta 60 DTE Comparison

The pricing spike in 2008 is the eye-catcher in Figure 5, but that is not the focus of our current discussion. Notice that while the VIX has settled near its long-term average over the period studied (19.1), the pricing for both contract types remains elevated after 2020.

For the 120 DTE trades (blue), notice how infrequently pricing has remained above the VIX line. For the 30 DTE trades (green), imagine a horizontal line moving left from the current VIX value. Wherever that line touches a VIX point, look down at the green scatter points and notice how much lower they are than our current pricing. 

While this volatility environment is historically unique, our data included other examples of increased downside protection costs, notably the 2008 Financial Crisis and 2018 trade war sell-off. What can those examples teach us about the duration of inflated protection pricing? 

How Long Do Price Spikes Last?

OTM put pricing increases during and following a volatility event. How long does it take for pricing to normalize after a spike in volatility? 

To answer this question, we looked at pricing spikes during the Financial Crisis, 2016, and 2018. 

To help visualize duration, we calculated the 60-day average contract cost before the pricing increases. That average is shown by the blue horizontal line in each plot. 

We defined mean reversion as when the pricing scatter plot fell below that 60-day average line for multiple trading days. As you will see in the plots, this did not always happen, and there may not be a “typical” duration of increased put protection pricing.

Financial Crisis Tail-Risk Pricing

Figure 6a - SPX 5 Delta 60 DTE Contract - Global Financial Crisis

As shown in Figure 6a, protection puts had a historic price spike in late 2008, but the extreme pricing reverted to normal levels within two weeks. The 2008 VIX spike was the largest on record before the Pandemic Crash in 2020. Despite that historic volatility, the extreme protection pricing appears to have had an insignificant duration. 

The scale of Figure 6a prevents us from seeing the more typical pricing trends produced by the volatility of the Financial Crisis. A second image will correct this.

Figure 6b - SPX 5 Delta 60 DTE financial crisis pricing excluding outliers

We plotted the same data as in the previous figure but removed the 11 high-magnitude data points. This lowered the left y-axis price scale from 1-100 to 1-10. The pre-event 60-day average and VIX values are unchanged. On this updated scale, it’s easier to see that pricing did not truly mean-revert for nearly six months. 

While there were short-lived, high-magnitude pricing increases in protection puts during the Financial Crisis, behind those extreme events were more sustained pricing increases and a slower reversion to the mean.

2015-2016 Tail Risk Pricing

Figure 7 - SPX 5 Delta 60 DTE Contract - 2016

In 2015, protection pricing rose as the market entered correction territory. Similar to the second example during the Financial Crisis, prices slowly mean reverted following the initial spike. While they did fall below the 60-day average about two months after the initial pricing increase, contract prices did not persist below that level until April 2016, nearly eight months after the initial price increase.

2018 Tail Risk Pricing

Figure 8 - SPX 5 Delta 60 DTE Contract - 2019-2019

In more recent memory, 2018 offers a unique look at the duration of elevated put pricing. Starting in February with inflation fears and ending with volatility due to the onset of the China-USA trade war, put protection pricing remained elevated the entire year. 

Throughout 2019, leading up to the Pandemic Crash, put protection prices never reverted to their previous level. 

These historical examples bring us back to our current focus. The Pandemic Crash elevated put pricing beyond its already historically high levels.

Figure 9 - SPX 5 Delta 60 DTE Contract - Pandemic Crash

Looking back through the charts, this pricing level relative to the VIX would have been unimaginable during previous volatility events. Protection pricing has fallen some since the Pandemic Crash but it is still well above the already-elevated previous levels.

The magnitude and duration of protection put pricing is largely unpredictable. However, we learned that the price to protect your portfolio with OTM puts has still not mean-reverted since the 2018 increase. The volatility from the Pandemic Crash took these prices to another level despite a strong recovery in the indices, and consistent new ATHs in the second half of 2020 and 2021.

The past does not give a reliable indication of how long elevated pricing will persist or if it will mean revert, but it appears that traders are preparing for the “unknown unknown” by prioritizing downside protection.

Tying It All Together

Hedge pricing has dramatically risen since the Pandemic Crash, with longer-dated options experiencing the highest increase. Historically, the duration of increased pricing has been largely unpredictable, with some events lasting only a few months and others persisting for years.

After a market correction or a significant spike in volatility, hedging is on many investors’ minds. With the pain of the last portfolio decline still fresh, traders line up for portfolio protection in hopes of preventing it from happening again. 

As demand rises for out-of-the-money protection, prices rise. There are opportunistic sellers to the buyers lining up for protection, willing to purchase puts despite the relatively high premiums. As markets settle down and volatility subsides, investors tire of paying premiums for portfolio protection and demand subsides, causing put prices to decline. Then, when a volatility event happens occurs, the unhedged are exposed yet again, and the cycle repeats. 

The price of portfolio protection ebbs and flows. When protection pricing is high, perhaps pursue alternative hedging strategies. When it is low, don’t get lulled into complacency and skip out on protecting your downside. 

Hedging
VIX
Research
Portfolio Management
Case Studies
Put Options
Volatility
You're on the list right?
Want to know when new posts go live? Subscribe to get updates each time we publish new training, research, or case studies. Autotrading is moving fast so don't get left behind.
‍
Thank you! Please click the verification link we just sent to your email address.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
We’ll never share your email address
Featured posts
How to Automate a Bollinger Band Strategy
How to Automate a Bollinger Band Strategy
March 31, 2022
We Analyzed 20,000 Options Trades: Here’s What We Learned About Position Swings
We Analyzed 20,000 Options Trades: Here’s What We Learned About Position Swings
March 25, 2022
Backtester Enhancements Unlock Research Superpowers for Options Traders
Backtester Enhancements Unlock Research Superpowers for Options Traders
February 22, 2022
Building an RSI Swing Trading Bot with Credit Spreads
Building an RSI Swing Trading Bot with Credit Spreads
December 13, 2021
3 Smart Ways to Use SmartStops
3 Smart Ways to Use SmartStops
December 8, 2021
5-Year SPY Put Credit Spread Backtest
5-Year SPY Put Credit Spread Backtest
November 17, 2021
Managing Multiple Strategy Types with Monitor Automations
Managing Multiple Strategy Types with Monitor Automations
June 30, 2021
Automated Does Not Mean Unattended
Automated Does Not Mean Unattended
May 19, 2021
Using Bots to Automate Profit Targets and Stop Losses
Using Bots to Automate Profit Targets and Stop Losses
April 19, 2021
Most popular
See All
13 Stock Chart Patterns that You Can’t Afford to Forget
13 Stock Chart Patterns that You Can’t Afford to Forget
6 min read
The Three Best Option Strategies for Earnings
The Three Best Option Strategies for Earnings
8 min read
How Can a Call Option Decline in Value When a Stock Rises?
How Can a Call Option Decline in Value When a Stock Rises?
3 min read
What Your Mother Didn’t Tell You About Trading Iron Condors
What Your Mother Didn’t Tell You About Trading Iron Condors
4 min read
4 Must Know Options Expiration Day Traps to Avoid
4 Must Know Options Expiration Day Traps to Avoid
5 min read
Problems Getting Your Option Order Filled? Try These 3 Quick Adjustments
Problems Getting Your Option Order Filled? Try These 3 Quick Adjustments
7 min read
5-Year SPY Put Credit Spread Backtest
5-Year SPY Put Credit Spread Backtest
7 min read
How to Set Up a Broken-Wing Butterfly Option Strategy
How to Set Up a Broken-Wing Butterfly Option Strategy
3 min read
3 Option Strategies to Use During Low Volatility Markets
3 Option Strategies to Use During Low Volatility Markets
2 min read
Naked Option Selling: The Stupid Myth of "Unlimited Losses"
Naked Option Selling: The Stupid Myth of "Unlimited Losses"
6 min read
Rising Interest Rates: Taper Tantrum or Opportunity?
Rising Interest Rates: Taper Tantrum or Opportunity?
5 min read
Mastering the 4 Different Types of Option Orders
Mastering the 4 Different Types of Option Orders
8 min read

No-code, fully automated trading for stocks and options.

HomeAboutLegalStatusContact
©2022 Option Alpha. All Rights Reserved. Patent Pending USSN 63/118,547